SCR 3-1118
SCR 3-1118: Resolve Documentation Requirement Inconsistencies (was “Add ICD, SISes to Volume Documentation in StdRef”)
Priority: medium
Problem Summary
Since section 3.5.1 of the Proposer’s Archive Guide states that “The most current version of the ICD should be included in the archive.”, the Standards Reference chapters 10 (“File Specification and Naming”) and 19 (“Volume Organization and Naming”) should be updated accordingly. Section 3.5.2 calls for the inclusion of data product and archive volume software interface specifications as well, so these, too, should be added.
Working Group
D. Simpson (lead) R. Joyner, T. King, S. Slavney
Originator: E. Rye
Standards Change Request
| Version | Date | Author(s) | Format | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2008-03-12 | R. Simpson | DOC | |
| 2 | 2008-04-16 | R. Simpson | DOC | |
| 3 | 2008-05-07 | R. Simpson | DOC | |
| 4 | 2008-05-22 | R. Simpson | DOC |
Discussion
- Discussion Blog
- Telecons: 2007-08-29 (HTML), 2007-09-12 (HTML), 2007-09-26 (WAV), 2007-10-17 (WAV), 2007-10-31 (HTML), 2007-11-14 (HTML), 2007-11-28 (HTML), 2008-01-09 (HTML), 2008-01-30 (HTML), 2008-02-13 (WAV), 2008-02-27 (HTML), 2008-03-19 (WAV), 2008-04-16 (WAV), 2008-05-07 (HTML), 2008-05-21 (HTML), 2008-06-04 (HTML)
Supplementary Material
- Proposer’s Archiving Guide (PAG) (03/12/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – Mar 12, 2008)
- Proposer’s Archiving Guide (PAG) with markup (03/12/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – Mar 12, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) (04/16/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – Apr 16, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) (05/20/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – May 20, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) with markup (05/20/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – May 20, 2008)
- Proposer’s Archiving Guide (PAG) (05/20/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – May 20, 2008)
- Proposer’s Archiving Guide (PAG) with markup (05/20/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – May 20, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) (05/22/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – May 22, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) with markup (05/22/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – May 22, 2008)
- Proposer’s Archiving Guide (PAG) (05/22/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – May 22, 2008)
- Proposer’s Archiving Guide (PAG) with markup (05/22/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – May 22, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) (06/04/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – Jun 4, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) (06/04/08; liens corrected) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – Jun 4, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) with markup (06/04/08) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – Jun 4, 2008)
- Archive Preparation Guide (APG) with markup (06/04/08; liens corrected) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – Jun 4, 2008)
- Proposer’s Archiving Guide (PAG) (06/04/08; liens corrected) (DOC, PDF) (D. Simpson, rev. – Jun 4, 2008)
Status
| Status | Date | Task | Responsible Party | Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SUBMITTED | 2007-05-22 | Submit issue. | ORIG | Issue submitted through online interface 05/22/07. |
| Form working group. | EN-SEORIG |
Votes
Version 3 of the SCR was approved by the Tech Group at the 05/21/08 telecon by a vote of 8-0-1 (yes-no-abstain) with a lien that the date on the cover of the APG be corrected from 2006 to 2008.
| Node | Representative | Version 3 |
|---|---|---|
| ATM | Lyle Huber | approve |
| EN | Elizabeth Rye | approve |
| GEO | Susie Slavney | approve |
| IMG | Chris Isbell | abstain |
| NAIF | Boris Semenov | approve |
| PPI | Todd King | approve |
| RINGS | Mitch Gordon | approve |
| RS | Dick Simpson | approve |
| SBN | Anne Raugh | approve |
The Tech Group voted at the 05/21/08 telecon by a vote of 8-0-1 (yes-no-abstain) to send the SCR, with the noted lien corrected, to the MC for approval.
| Node | Representative | Version 3 |
|---|---|---|
| ATM | Lyle Huber | submit to MC for vote |
| EN | Elizabeth Rye | submit to MC for vote |
| GEO | Susie Slavney | submit to MC for vote |
| IMG | Chris Isbell | abstain |
| NAIF | Boris Semenov | submit to MC for vote |
| PPI | Todd King | submit to MC for vote |
| RINGS | Mitch Gordon | submit to MC for vote |
| RS | Dick Simpson | submit to MC for vote |
| SBN | Anne Raugh | submit to MC for vote |
Version 4 of the SCR, with the noted liens, was approved by the Tech Group at the 06/04/08 telecon by a vote of 7-0-1-1 (yes-no-abstain-absent).
| Node | Representative | Version 4 |
|---|---|---|
| ATM | absent | – |
| EN | Elizabeth Rye | yes |
| GEO | Susie Slavney | yes |
| IMG | Chris Isbell1 | abstain |
| NAIF | Boris Semenov | yes |
| PPI | Todd King | yes |
| RINGS | Mitch Gordon | yes |
| RS | Dick Simpson | yes |
| SBN | Anne Raugh | yes |
1
“Abstain” vote due to having just arrived on telecon.
The Tech Group voted at the 06/04/08 telecon by a vote of 8-0-1 (yes-no-absent) to send the SCR, with the noted liens, to the MC for approval.
| Node | Representative | Version 4 |
|---|---|---|
| ATM | absent | – |
| EN | Elizabeth Rye | submit to MC for vote |
| GEO | Susie Slavney | submit to MC for vote |
| IMG | Chris Isbell | submit to MC for vote |
| NAIF | Boris Semenov | submit to MC for vote |
| PPI | Todd King | submit to MC for vote |
| RINGS | Mitch Gordon | submit to MC for vote |
| RS | Dick Simpson | submit to MC for vote |
| SBN | Anne Raugh | submit to MC for vote |
Version 4 of the SCR was approved by the MC via an email vote ending on 07/29/09 by a vote of 8-0-1 (yes-no-no vote).
| Node | Representative | Version 4 |
|---|---|---|
| GEO | R. Arvidson | yes |
| IMG | L. Gaddis | yes |
| PPI | R. Walker | yes |
| RINGS | M. Showalter | yes |
| SBN | – | no vote |
| NAIF | C. Acton | yes |
| RS | D. Simpson | yes |