SCR 3-1150: Change minimum value for detector_temperature
Priority: medium
Problem Summary: From sample data from Messenger's MESS-E/V/H-MDIS-2-EDR-RAWDATA-V1.0:
DETECTOR_TEMPERATURE = -24.21 <DEGC>
The data dictionary has unit = K and minimum = 0. However, the sample label has <DEGC> (which is legal), but vtool still flags the negative value as an error.
Working group: R. Chen (lead) NULL
Originator: Richard Chen
Standards Change Request:
| Version | Date | Author(s) | Format | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2009-07-27 | E. Rye | DOCX | |
Discussion:
- Discussion Blog
- Telecons: 2009-02-11 (MP3), 2009-03-11 (HTML), 2009-04-08 (), 2009-04-29 (HTML), 2009-05-27 (HTML), 2009-06-24 (HTML), 2009-07-15 (HTML), 2009-07-29 (HTML)
Supplementary Material:
Status:
| Status | Task | ResponsibleParty | Response |
|---|---|---|---|
| SUBMITTED 2009-02-04 | Submit issue. | ORIG | Issue submitted through online interface 02/04/09. |
| Form working group. | EN-SEORIG |
Votes:
At the 07/29/09 Standards Telecon, the TG approved version 1 of this SCR by a vote of 6-0-1-2 (yes-no-abstain-absent).
| Node | Representative | Version 1 |
|---|---|---|
| ATM | absent | |
| EN | E. Rye | yes |
| GEO | S. Slavney | yes |
| IMG | P. Garcia | yes |
| NAIF | B. Semenov | yes |
| PPI | T. King | yes |
| RINGS | absent | |
| RS | D. Simpson | abstain |
| SBN | A. Raugh | yes |
At the 07/29/09 Standards Telecon, the TG decided by a vote of 6-0-1-2 (yes-no-abstain-absent) that it recommended against an MC vote on version 1 of this SCR.
| Node | Representative | Version 1 |
|---|---|---|
| ATM | absent | |
| EN | E. Rye | MC vote unwarranted |
| GEO | S. Slavney | MC vote unwarranted |
| IMG | P. Garcia | MC vote unwarranted |
| NAIF | B. Semenov | MC vote unwarranted |
| PPI | T. King | MC vote unwarranted |
| RINGS | absent | |
| RS | D. Simpson | abstain |
| SBN | A. Raugh | submit to MC for vote |