Planetary Data System
Engineering Node

PDS3 Standards: Individual Issue

SCR 3-1150: Change minimum value for detector_temperature

Priority: medium


Problem Summary: From sample data from Messenger's MESS-E/V/H-MDIS-2-EDR-RAWDATA-V1.0:

DETECTOR_TEMPERATURE = -24.21 <DEGC>

The data dictionary has unit = K and minimum = 0. However, the sample label has <DEGC> (which is legal), but vtool still flags the negative value as an error.


Working group: R. Chen (lead) NULL

Originator: Richard Chen


Standards Change Request:

Version Date Author(s) Format Note
1 2009-07-27 E. Rye DOCX
PDF

Discussion:


Supplementary Material:


Status:

Status Task ResponsibleParty Response
SUBMITTED 2009-02-04 Submit issue. ORIG Issue submitted through online interface 02/04/09.
Form working group. EN-SEORIG

Votes:

At the 07/29/09 Standards Telecon, the TG approved version 1 of this SCR by a vote of 6-0-1-2 (yes-no-abstain-absent).

Node Representative Version 1
ATM absent
EN E. Rye yes
GEO S. Slavney yes
IMG P. Garcia yes
NAIF B. Semenov yes
PPI T. King yes
RINGS absent
RS D. Simpson abstain
SBN A. Raugh yes

At the 07/29/09 Standards Telecon, the TG decided by a vote of 6-0-1-2 (yes-no-abstain-absent) that it recommended against an MC vote on version 1 of this SCR.

Node Representative Version 1
ATM absent
EN E. Rye MC vote unwarranted
GEO S. Slavney MC vote unwarranted
IMG P. Garcia MC vote unwarranted
NAIF B. Semenov MC vote unwarranted
PPI T. King MC vote unwarranted
RINGS absent
RS D. Simpson abstain
SBN A. Raugh submit to MC for vote