The following notes were taken by Ron Joyner (except where noted). Corrections are welcome. (Notes in red indicate updates after the telecon.)
Planetary Data System Standards Teleconference
June 24, 2009 9-11 AM
Announcements:
None
Telecon Discussions:
1. SCR status:
- SCR3-1127: Pointer/Object Ambiguity in the Standards Reference
WG: T. King (lead), M. Cayanan, L. Huber, S. Hughes, R. Joyner
- Version 5 of the SCR was sent out for an e-vote on 06/18/09. The vote is scheduled to end on 07/06/09. --EDR
- A. Raugh indicated that the SCR didn't have enough discussion. R. Simpson changed his vote from Yes to No.
- Real-time vote:
Node Voter Vote? Send to
MC?ATM L. Huber not present GEO S. Slavney yes IMG P. Garcia yes NAIF B. Semenov abstain PPI T. King not present* RINGS M. Gordon no RS D. Simpson no SBN A. Raugh no EN R. Joyner yes
*PPI submitted a vote of "yes" through the web interface a couple of hours after the telecon. --EDR- A. Raugh will re-write the sentence containing 'instance'.
- R. Simpson will "add to" the SCR; re-write SCR
- R. Joyner to research affect of the Rosetta labels on EN tools (NASAView, VLTool, VTool)
- R. Joyner is now lead
- SCR3-1141: Increase DATA_QUALITY_ID to 16 characters
WG: R. Chen (lead), E. Rye
- R. Simpson recommended adding a PPI person to the working group, given that they are the lead node on the mission. E. Rye has asked S. Joy to join the group and sent him the SCR to review but has received no response. --EDR
- Version 3 of the SCR has been updated to address the issue of the StdRef example in Section 5.5.1. The SCR has been posted on the web site. --EDR
- R. Joyner said that the note containing the breakdown of the MDIS byte field was too detailed and wanted it taken out. R. Chen said he would do so. --EDR
- R. Chen also remembered a few comments from A. Raugh that he intends to fix. --EDR
- R. Chen will re-write SCR and issue version 4. --EDR
- E. Rye pointed out to R. Joyner after telecon that since MDIS labels do not contain DATA_QUALITY_DESC keyword, it is important that the information in the proposed note field be retained. He agreed. --EDR
- SCR3-1145: PSDD Filename Length Clean-Up
WG: S. Slavney (lead), M. Gordon, R. Joyner, E. Rye
- Version 2 of the SCR was posted on 06/02/09. --EDR
- Ready for discussion and possible vote. --EDR
- Susie indicated that the most current version of the SCR is not posted and she will email me to post.
- SCR3-1146: Update reference format to handle DOIs
WG: A. Raugh (lead), P. Garcia, S. Hughes, R. Joyner, R. Simpson, S. Slavney, R. Walker (consult)
- Several potential options were discussed at the last telecon. The working group needs to determine which, if any, of these they wish to write up in the SCR. They'll need to put together a version 2, which we can then distribute for further discussion. --EDR
- R. Simpson will send review comments to Anne to incorporate into a replacement.
- SCR3-1148: Phoenix keywords
WG: E. Rye (lead), S. Slavney, B. Sword
- Template for seven keywords have been sent to E. Rye. She's in the process of writing up the SCR and hopes to have it posted soon. --EDR
- SCR3-1150: Change minimum value for detector_temperature
WG: R. Chen (lead), E. Rye
- After last telecon, E. Rye had conversation with P. Ramirez in which he brought up some concerns about our proposed solution but Rye couldn't remember content in time to inform R. Joyner for this telecon. (See minutes of last telecon for details.) --EDR
- E. Rye to pass comments from previous Standards telecon to tools group for response.
- Note that I talked with P. Ramirez yesterday and I will forward his email.
- SCR3-1151: Change TELEMETRY_FORMAT_ID from STATIC to SUGGESTED
WG: R. Chen (lead), S. Joy, B. Sword, E. Rye
- R. Chen to research DAWN standard values and write SCR.
- R. Simpson knows lots about history of this keyword which should probably be added to keyword description. --EDR
2. Further Issues:
- None
Next telecon scheduled for 2009-07-15.