SCR 3-1064: Increase length of PATH_NAME
Priority: medium
Problem Summary: Based on the approval of SCR 3-1006, the length of PATH_NAME needs to be increased to accomodate longer directory names.
Working group: E. Rye (lead)
Originator: E. Rye
Standards Change Request:
Version | Date | Author(s) | Format | Note |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2007-01-29 | R. Joyner | DOC | provisionally approved version |
provisionally approved version | ||||
2 | 2007-02-06 | R. Joyner | DOC | provisionally approved version; with changes |
provisionally approved version; with changes | ||||
3 | 2007-03-01 | A. Raugh | DOC | |
Discussion:
Supplementary Material:
Status:
Status | Task | ResponsibleParty | Response |
---|---|---|---|
SUBMITTED 2006-01-13 | |||
IN_PROGRESS 2007-01-29 | |||
DRAFT 2007-01-29 | |||
RECOMMENDED 2007-03-06 | |||
APPROVED 2007-04-03 | |||
IN_IMPLEMENTATION 2007-04-03 | |||
RELEASED 2007-04-03 |
Votes:
Vote to RECOMMEND version 2 of the SCR be moved to Implementation stage.
Node | Representative | Version 2 |
---|---|---|
ATM | Lyle Huber | yes |
GEO | Susie Slavney | yes |
IMG | Patty Garcia | yes |
NAIF | Boris Semenov1 | no |
PPI | Steve Joy | yes |
RINGS | Mitch Gordon2 | no |
RS | Dick Simpson3 | no |
SBN | Anne Raugh4 | no |
1 Agree with SBN: the number needs to be revised to be compiant with hard media approved for deep archiving 2Based on Annes blog, we need to set the upper limit to 255 to retain ISSO 9660. I would vote yes with that change. 3per Annes argument that it violates ISO 9660 4The length requested (287 characters) violates the ISO 9660 standard. |
Vote to RECOMMEND version 3 of the SCR be moved to Implementation stage.
Node | Representative | Version 3 |
---|---|---|
ATM | Lyle Huber | yes |
EN | Steve Hughes | yes |
GEO | Susie Slavney | yes |
IMG | Patty Garcia1 | yes |
NAIF | Boris Semenov | yes |
PPI | Todd King | yes |
RINGS | Mitch Gordon | yes |
RS | Dick Simpson2 | yes |
SBN | Anne Raugh | yes |
1(also requires change to "NAME" keyword.) 2But I am a little worried that some of these labels/files will become unreadable if the new, longer length options are taken to extremes. |